04.07.2024

A new social contract – a way to wellbeing for all?

In this blog, we discuss how the framework of a social contract can help us understand the crises we’re living through, and explore solutions to them on route towards a good life for all.

By Daniela Negruti

We all want to be able to look optimistically into tomorrow while trusting that we can have a say in the decisions that will affect us and peoples’ wellbeing on the planet.

Multiple and overlapping crises characterise the today’s social, political, and ecological context. These are largely due to structural flaws in our economic system. And while some crises loom large in our collective imaginations, notably the climate emergency, other emerging crises, such as the ‘inequality crisis’, are also at play.

Against the backdrop of rising backlash and tensions across Europe, protest movements point to people fighting to protect themselves and the planet from decisions that will affect them for decades. At the root, these frustrations stem from a social contract no longer fit for purpose. One that needs to be renegotiated.

But what is a social contract?

According to Saujot, M., Bet, M., Abdallah, S., Bengtsson, M., Rogers, C. (2024), the social contract can be resumed in four ‘pacts’ representing key dimensions of our social life and a space of autonomy in which individuals can realise a good life:

  • Consumption,
  • Democracy,
  • Security and
  • Work.

People accept the current systems for consumption, democracy, security, and work, and certain disadvantages that come with them, provided they receive sufficient benefits.

The social contract and its pacts define our collective life and hold it together, with deals and ‘exchanges’ between the members of a society encompassing the rights, obligations, and responsibilities that each side claims.

Fixing a broken social contract

The concept of the social contract can be used as a lens to understand the current challenges and the rules that govern our societies, and as a tool to foster change.

With the start of the next 5-year cycle of the EU institutions this year, the timing couldn’t be better to revisit the social contract. Like with any contract, we can renew or renegotiate these agreements. The question is,

how do we negotiate today with the values of the past on which the existing social contact is based, in order to plant the seeds for a renewed social contract for the future?

Building on a long-term dialogue about how a new social contract can lead to a sustainable society, ZOE Institute’s Magalí Brosio participated in a webinar based on the new report “How Did We Get Here? A Short History of 19th and 20th Century Social Contracts in France and the UK” by IDDRI and the Hot or Cool Institute.

“With many people’s basic needs not being met, it’s clear that our social contracts require an overhaul. To effectively transition to a wellbeing economy, these new pacts must address both global and intergenerational dimensions,” Magalí told the event.

Renegotiating together

A social contract is essential for advancing a strong beyond growth agenda. Although the current dominant narrative built around economic growth as the ultimate indicator of progress and prosperity has been heavily criticised for decades, no alternative vision has had a strong impact on public policy at national or international level.

GDP alone does not capture what people value. What people really value should be embedded in pacts and narratives that resonate with them. This is something we are dealing with at ZOE Institute, including through our WISE Horizons project.

What is needed for an inclusive and sustainable wellbeing narrative to be crystalised into actual policy?

The concept of social contract fits well into ZOE’s theory of change. It is particularly instrumental to the development of a coherent paradigm. This is something ZOE works towards, for example through co-creative labs. The WISE Horizons Future and Just Transition Labs which took place in 2023 unpacked the concepts of wellbeing, inclusion and sustainability together with stakeholders with diverse backgrounds and expertise, and explored the impact of policies on their lives.

The social contract approach emerged as an essential tool for navigating these discussions.

People’s support is crucial, and for this it is essential to allow them to drive the transition. By doing so, the policies we implement will not only be inclusive but also have the long-term support of the citizens.

Pacts towards a just transition

Social contracts defined at the national level in wealthy countries often neglect or harm people in low-income countries, a critical concern if we are to develop a 21st-century social contract capable of addressing the ecological, social, and economic challenges of our time.

“A pact in which one pays the cost and the other gets the benefits is hardly a pact.” – Magalí

For instance, an analysis from Oxfam France shows that it is the poorest who bear the costs of the climate and energy crisis, while the richest are responsible for it. The inherent limitations of national governments in dealing with global problems are evident, as today’s crises cannot be resolved at the national level alone.

To achieve change rooted in the community, we need to create a framework that fosters public engagement in an accessible, inclusive, and meaningful way. For this, we propose:

  • Multilateral fora are a well-placed platform for developing international coordination and cooperation and they should be strengthened
  • Channels for civic participation and engagement, enhanced and adapted to our role as global citizens. For example, this could relate to the democracy pact, and extend it to consider how political participation should look in a world in which the consequences of our decisions transcend borders.

These can provide a solid foundation for renegotiating a social contract that can deliver wellbeing for all, now and in the future.